Monday, December 22, 2008

Shaykh Thanvi commiting shirk???







Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvi says
" ( O Pophet!) you are the one who reveals what is hidden in our heart".

Now this is clear that Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvee al deobandi is attributing the knwoledge of unseen to prophet ! ( Hayatul Muslimeen,page 9 )
( how else will prophet come to know the secret of heart??)




Please recall , Imam e rabbani of the deobandis , Shaykh Rashid Gangohi said
"any one who says prophet was given the knowledge of the unseen , then he is in shirk"

( Fatwa Rashdiya)


If the fatwa of imam e rabbani of the deoabandis is correct , then shaykh Ashraf ali thanvee commiited shirk!

2. Shaykh Ashraf ali thnavee further writes
" (O prophet) you are the one who provides relief from difficulty to those in need "

Is it not clear that Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvi is calling prophet as Mushkil Kusha.?
( remover of difficulty)

The "shahid" of the deobandis Ismail Dehalvi who killed innocent sunni muslims , wrote in his tafwiyatul iman
" if any one considers besides Allah to provide relief ( from difficulty),then they are in shirk".

So now Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvi has commited shirk as per Ismail dehalvi.


3. Hakim Al Ummah of the deobandis , Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvi writes
" ( O prophet! ) if you hide ( ghayab) or become absent then death will come and world will go into darkness"

Here Shaykh Ashraf ali thanvee is accepting prophet to be " Hazir and Nazir"!

1 comment:

A.D.H.M said...

Deobandi deviant Ramzan Numani challenges Munazir e Islam Allama Saeed As'ad
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=24YIpWlV_XI

Could you please give more info on this challenge?
Regarding Allama Saeed As'ads response?
I can not find any info on the web or forums???